People new to self-employment are often surprised by how much of routine healthcare they now pay for directly. Provincial plans cover physician and hospital care — a great deal — but a substantial category of everyday costs sits outside them.
What provincial coverage leaves out
- Prescription medication outside hospital, for most adults under 65
- Dental care, from cleanings to major work
- Vision — eye exams for many adults, and glasses or contacts
- Paramedical services — physiotherapy, chiropractic, massage, psychology
- Ambulance fees, in many provinces
- Medical devices — braces, hearing aids, mobility equipment
- Private or semi-private hospital rooms
For a healthy single person these may total little. For a family with children, orthodontics, prescriptions and a couple of physio courses a year, they add up to real money.
How individual plans work
Individual health and dental plans are structured differently from group coverage, and the differences matter.
Annual maximums per category — a dental maximum, a paramedical maximum per practitioner type, a vision allowance every two years. These are typically lower than comparable group plans.
Co-insurance — plans often cover a percentage rather than the full cost, commonly 70–80% for basic services and less for major dental.
Waiting periods — particularly for major dental. It is common to wait a year before crowns or orthodontics are covered, which prevents people buying a plan the week before expensive work.
Underwriting — some plans ask health questions and may exclude pre-existing conditions. Others are guaranteed-issue with lower limits. If you have ongoing prescription needs, read this section carefully, because a plan that excludes your existing medication is of limited use.
The honest question: is it worth it?
I will not pretend the answer is always yes.
Individual health and dental plans are priced so the insurer expects to collect more than it pays out — that is how insurance works. For someone with predictable, modest costs, self-insuring by setting money aside can be the better financial choice.
The case for a plan is stronger when:
- You have ongoing prescription costs, which can be substantial and recurring
- You have children, particularly with orthodontics ahead
- You use paramedical services regularly for a chronic issue
- You want budget predictability rather than lumpy annual costs
- You are concerned about a high-cost drug, where catastrophic coverage matters
The case is weaker for a healthy single person with no regular prescriptions, no dental problems and a decent emergency fund. For them, a dedicated savings buffer may genuinely be better value.
Most provinces have programmes covering high drug costs relative to income, or specific coverage for seniors and certain conditions. These are not always well publicised. Confirm what you already qualify for before buying private coverage to fill a gap that may be partly filled already.
The incorporated business option
If you operate through a corporation, ask your accountant about a Health Spending Account. Rather than buying an insurance plan, the corporation reimburses eligible medical expenses, generally as a deductible business expense, and the benefit is typically non-taxable to you.
For an incorporated business owner with predictable medical costs, this is often more efficient than a traditional plan, because you are converting after-tax personal spending into a deductible business expense rather than paying premiums for pooled risk. It suits routine costs better than catastrophic ones — some owners pair a Health Spending Account with a high-deductible plan for the large, unlikely events.
What to compare
Do not compare on premium alone. Look at the annual maximum per category against what you actually spend, the co-insurance percentage, the waiting periods for anything you need soon, whether existing conditions and current prescriptions are covered, and whether there is meaningful protection for catastrophic drug costs.
A cheap plan that excludes your prescriptions and caps dental at a low figure may cost more than it returns.
If you want help working out whether a plan makes sense for your actual spending — including the honest answer that it might not — that is a conversation worth having.
What provincial coverage leaves out
| Covered by OHIP | Not covered — yours to fund |
|---|---|
| Hospital stays and surgery | Prescription drugs (most adults under 65) |
| Physician visits | Dental, almost entirely |
| Diagnostic imaging | Vision — exams for most adults, and all eyewear |
| Emergency care | Physiotherapy, chiropractic, massage, psychology |
| Some home care | Medical equipment and devices |
The right column is what a group plan normally covers and what disappears the day you go self-employed. The prescription row is the one that matters most: a single ongoing medication can run into hundreds a month, and specialty drugs far more.
Ontario does have programs that help in specific circumstances — the Trillium Drug Program for households whose drug costs are high relative to income, and OHIP+ for those under 25 without other coverage. Check your eligibility directly with the province rather than assuming you have nothing.
The honest question: is a plan worth it?
For routine costs, frequently not. Individual health plans are priced so that the insurer expects to collect more than it pays for predictable items. If your annual dental and vision spending is modest, you will usually pay more in premiums than you claim.
Where a plan earns its cost is the unpredictable and large: a drug you did not anticipate needing, a long course of physiotherapy after an accident, a child's orthodontics, a mental health condition requiring months of therapy. That is the risk worth transferring.
So the sensible question is not "will I get my money back?" — on routine items you probably will not. It is "could I absorb a sudden $20,000 drug cost?" If the answer is no, you are insuring the right thing.
A practical middle route: choose a plan with a strong drug maximum and a modest dental benefit rather than the reverse. Many people buy the opposite because dental is the cost they can picture.
The incorporated option that is often better
If you are incorporated, a Health Spending Account is frequently better value than an individual plan.
The company pays medical expenses through a formally established plan. The amounts are generally deductible to the corporation and generally not a taxable benefit to you — so you are paying with pre-tax corporate dollars instead of after-tax personal ones. On the same out-of-pocket cost, that is a meaningful difference.
Three caveats. It must meet CRA's requirements for a private health services plan, not simply be the company paying your dentist. The rules differ depending on whether you have arm's-length employees. And an HSA is an allowance, not insurance — it will not absorb a catastrophic drug cost, so pairing it with a plan that carries a high drug maximum is usually right.
Confirm the structure with your accountant before setting one up; getting this wrong converts a deduction into taxable income.
Sole proprietors: the deduction you may be missing
Unincorporated self-employed people can, under certain conditions, deduct premiums paid for a private health services plan against business income rather than claiming only the medical expense tax credit. Conditions apply, including rules about whether you have employees and limits on the amount.
It is worth asking your accountant specifically, because it is commonly missed — many sole proprietors assume health premiums are purely personal.
Failing that, premiums and out-of-pocket medical costs may qualify for the medical expense tax credit, which is worth claiming even though it only helps above an income-based threshold. Keep every receipt, including amounts a plan declined.
What to compare
- The annual drug maximum — the single most important number.
- Whether there is a lifetime cap on anything, and where.
- Dental: percentage reimbursed, annual limit, and the waiting period before major work is eligible.
- Paramedical limits per practitioner type, which are often low.
- Whether acceptance is guaranteed or medically underwritten — guaranteed plans exclude pre-existing conditions.
- Whether you can convert from a former group plan without medical questions, which usually has a 60-day deadline. See leaving your job benefits.
That last point is the one people discover too late. If you have recently left employment, check the conversion window before shopping the open market.
Get in touch if you would like help comparing, or see disability insurance for the self-employed — which, for most self-employed people, matters more than dental.
A sensible sequence
- Check whether you still have a conversion right from a former group plan — it has a short deadline and needs no medical questions.
- Check provincial programs you may qualify for, such as Trillium in Ontario if drug costs are high relative to income.
- Decide what you are actually insuring — the catastrophic drug risk, not the predictable dental.
- If incorporated, price a Health Spending Account alongside a plan with a strong drug maximum.
- Ask your accountant about the deduction for a private health services plan.
- Then sort disability cover, which matters more than any of the above.
That last step deserves the emphasis. Self-employed people reliably buy dental and skip income protection, because dental costs are visible and monthly while a disability feels hypothetical. The hypothetical one is what ends businesses.